File a Claim
Click on your carrier for a direct link to file a claim online
Utica First Insurance Company
For After Hours Emergencies Only: 1-800-456-4556 Option
For Utica First - during business hours - call Heritage Insurance Agency to report your claim, they don't have non-emergency direct claims reporting.
We want to know about your claims experience with our carriers. Please contact us at 717-684-6409 with feedback during and after your claim.
We want to know the good & the not-so-good.
It helps to know when our companies are doing a good job. We also want to know if there is a concern. If you get us involved in a dispute, we will do everything in our power to ensure that the carrier handles the claim correctly.
We have great relationships with our insurance carrier partners, and we're not hesitant to reach out to them to help you resolve a claim.