About Us

A Trusted Columbia PA Insurance Agent

Founded by F. Louis Nardo in May, 1976, Heritage Insurance Agency is a proud corporate resident of Columbia, Pa. – a classic American small town with friendly people and a rich local history.

Since its founding, Heritage Insurance Agency has been dedicated to providing the very best Pennsylvania insurance services to our clients.  Dedicated to our client’s success, Heritage Insurance Agency is a trusted PA insurance company providing an independent perspective to the insurance purchasing process.

In its early days, Heritage Insurance Agency focused on Pennsylvania homeowners and business insurance – auto insurance was purchased less frequently because the coverage was not yet required by law.

After the financial responsibility law was enacted, Heritage Insurance Agency added PA auto insurance to our insurance products portfolio, helping new and existing clients navigate this new Pennsylvania insurance requirement.

Lou Nardo eventually sold Heritage Insurance Agency, choosing to be near family in Virginia.   Gerard Clunan and Gregory Boll acquired Heritage Insurance Agency in January of 2011, forming New Heritage Insurance, LLC.  As full time financial planners with Hershey Financial Advisers, Jerry and Greg decided to add a partner with extensive Property and Casualty insurance experience.

Nate Bunty, CIC joined Heritage Insurance Agency as Managing Partner after establishing himself as a successful PA business insurance representative for Erie Insurance.

Heritage Insurance Agency’s tradition of independence and excellent service provides the basis for our Core Mission:

  • Serve our customers first.
  • Represent our insurance company partners well.
  • Provide the right insurance solution at the best price.

These guiding principles direct us as we assist our clients navigating through the Pennsylvania insurance marketplace.  We put your needs first when shopping for a PA home insurance or auto insurance policy.

We don’t “sell” anything

We consult with each client to find out what’s important to them, and then recommend the Pennsylvania insurance company with the insurance policy that best fits their needs!

There are a few important things to know as you made your insurance decisions.  Click each link below for more information.

Why an independent agent?

Who are our Pennsylvania Insurance Carrier Partners?

Meet Our Staff

Client Testimonials

Get the conversation started with a Trusted Choice, independent agency that has many years of experience – Heritage Insurance Agency!

Fill out our fast and convenient quote request form here or give us a call at 717-684-6409.

Call Email Claims Payments